City Island Pizza Company

About

Make a reservation at City Island Pizza Company, where authentic Italian cuisine meets a cozy, inviting atmosphere in the heart of City Island, New York. This beloved pizzeria is renowned for its signature dishes, including the mouthwatering Red Hot Chili Pepper Pizza, topped with n’duja and hot Italian sausage, and the $25 unlimited Sunday Supper, featuring bucatini with rich Sunday gravy and tender meatballs. The warm, candlelit dining room creates a perfect setting for casual dinners, where conversation flows as easily as the wine. Diners especially love the parmesan-crusted polenta fries, a must-try appetizer that perfectly complements any meal. With a focus on quality ingredients and traditional recipes, City Island Pizza Company offers an authentic taste of Italy that keeps locals and visitors coming back for more. The restaurant's friendly service and reasonable prices make it an ideal spot for families and friends alike. Don't miss out on their impressive wine program, featuring a selection of fine wines to pair with your meal. Whether you're a City Island resident or just visiting, make sure to secure your reservation to experience one of the best Italian dining experiences in NYC.